How one woman found yoga, eased her inner hunger, and started loving herself. Follow Kimber as she shares her journey to loving her body, the joys and sorrows of yoga teaching, and venturing into the wilderness of writing and publishing.

Friday, September 9, 2011

The Fat Yogi


Can yogis be fat? Can you be fat and practice yoga and live a healthy life? The answer is another question… does Ganesha have a big belly? Of course. Ganesha, the round-bellied elephant-headed god and mythological author of the sacred epic text that defines the ancient practice of yoga, would undoubtedly have some choice words to share with anyone who thinks proficient yogis can’t be fat.

Yet why do most yoga classes seem to be full of thin- to average-sized bodies? I’ve seen fat students do amazing armbalances, handstands, and poses my body has never quite figured out. So I know that it’s not a matter of flexibility or strength. I suspect that it’s related to the reason some fat people don’t feel comfortable at the gym… a subtle (and sometime not so subtle) sense of not feeling welcome or included.

We can start with the clothes. Long gone are the days when people showed up for yoga in their sweats and ripped up t-shirts. Nowadays (for women anyway) tank tops and fancy yoga pants seem de rigueur. Try finding a pair of yoga pants in anything larger than a size twelve and a tank top actually meant for something other than decoration. In most mainstream stores, the yoga clothing search is more frustrating than looking for a duck egg at a chicken farm.

The poses don’t help either. Some poses feel great, others feel… is there some word that means screamingly awkward? Some teachers aren’t sure how to modify poses for larger bodies or may make assumptions about a student’s ability based on their weight. Or teachers might give up too soon when assisting a fat student, thinking that their weight is the obstacle. Some poses may be genuinely more difficult… but not any more so than for an average weight student whose body has its own quirks and challenges. Yoga poses feel awkward to everyone… at least at first.

But the worst are the underlying assumptions (by other students and sometimes the teacher or the studio as a whole) that a fat person in a yoga class is unhappy with their body or is trying to lose weight. Feeling accepted as a fat person in yoga is complicated by the prevalence of classes like “Yoga for Weight Loss” that the desk staff might direct you to. You’d be understandably confused… isn’t part of yoga learning to love and accept yourself and your body just as it is, just as you are? Can I just enjoy a yoga class in my bigger body without feeling judged or excluded? Yes, you can. Yoga is an amazing way to connect with and listen to your body, and is not and has never been, as Ganesha reminds us, the exclusive dominion of the youthful and thin.

Yoga instructors (myself included) can do more to be welcoming to fat students. First, if you find that you’re carrying around a lot of judgments about weight, like the popular fat=unhealthy trope, read nutritionist and researcher Linda Bacon’s book, Health At Every Size: The Surprising Truth About Your Weight. Most yoga teachers I know enjoy having their assumptions challenged… you’ll find no shortage of mind-blowing insights in Bacon’s book.

Second, if you have a fat student in your class, here’s what you should do differently: nothing. That’s right. Treat them with exactly the same level of respect and attention that you would give any other student. Don’t make assumptions about their level or ability, or god forbid, that they are practicing yoga to lose weight. They might be there to lengthen their hamstrings, or to commune with the gods of bliss, or to relax after a hellish commute, or for some other reason that has nothing to do with their size. At the same time, just like with any other student, if you think they look like they could benefit from a prop or some other individual assistance, go right ahead and offer away. Like any other student, they might welcome your help, or they might tell you they’re fine and don’t need to go deeper into Ardha Matsendrasana, thank you very much.

If you’re a fat yoga student (or wanna be yoga student), do a little research on Ganesha, the long-trunked, full-bellied master wisdom jester of yoga. Keep a little picture of Ganesha in your mind and heart while you’re practicing… he welcomes you and helps you clear whatever internal and external obstacles lie on your path to yoga and self-discovery. Look around for a yoga teacher and studio that feel welcoming. Talk to the teacher and find out if they know about the Health At Every Size movement, and if they don’t, encourage them to read the book. Ask them for help when (and if) you need it, and feel free to show them what modifications work best for you and your body. Most yoga instructors are happy (dare I say eager?) to learn new assists. And be patient with yourself and your body. Let your body teach you.

If you’re brand new to yoga and want some help learning the poses before you show up in class, try some videos at home…the heavyweight yoga DVD series at http://www.heartfeltyoga.com/shop.htm is a good place to start.

If you are someone who struggles with feeling accepted (whatever size you are), write across the top of your yoga mat, “I am welcome here,” as a reminder to welcome yourself wherever you are.

It’s a beautiful reminder to anyone who sees your mat to welcome you as well. Welcoming is a lesson so many of us need… to welcome ourselves into our own body, our own practice, and to welcome each other, wherever and however we find ourselves. Welcome to yoga, my friend. Yoga welcomes you, your belly, your hips, your thighs… every part of your whole self.

Love Your Body Blog Part 60

11 comments:

  1. Kimber, I'm so happy to read this post! Thank you. There is definitely a feeling that yoga is only for skinny young women (and biased toward skinny young white women, at that). I've certainly been to plenty of yoga classes where mine is the biggest body there, and I'm only a size 12 -- the size that I just read on WebMD is what the average American woman wears. (Actually, they said the average lady wears size 12-14.) I've been practicing yoga long enough that my size doesn't make me (too) self-conscious anymore, but I have friends who are very reluctant to try yoga, and I suspect that their size is a big part of that issue. That, and the misconception that yoga is only for people who are already flexible. I mean, it's awkward and embarrassing enough to learn anything new in front of other people, but when you suspect those people will be judging you for your weight, too, well -- no one wants to be in that position! Quite frankly, I wouldn't either; it's lucky for me that I started yoga 20 pounds ago, because in my current body I might be too intimidated to enter a studio. Even though it's a gorgeous body! Because it's not a size 6, and because I have tight hamstrings, shoulders, and hips. ;b

    As to how teachers should treat bigger students, one thing I've always liked is when teachers tell us to manually move our flesh out of the way during a pose. That's something you do when we get into our simple cross-legged pose at the beginning of class (well, you're telling us to change the rotation, but we still have to use our hands to move our thighs), and I think other teachers have mentioned it for other poses (janu sirsasana, maybe -- I sometimes need to shift my belly for that one). Sometimes everyone's got flesh that moves around in the pose (like that cross-legs one), sometimes thinner people don't, but I just love the acknowledgement that yes, there's FLESH on these bodies of ours, and yes, it is okay to touch it and move it around. And on that note, sometimes it's not just "fat" I need to move around, but my breasts. D-cup boobs can really get in the way of some poses! ;)

    Another thing I love is when teachers notice things that are individual about my body. I don't know if it's just me or whether a lot of people who grew up thinking they were fat feel the same way, but there are SO many things about my body that I long assumed would be different if only I were thin. For instance, I spent my entire life thinking that my knees were funny-looking knees because I was overweight. Then when I was about 20, I went to a yoga class, and the teacher pointed out that my knees hyperextend -- just like hers. That's when I realized that my body might be built a certain way, and it has nothing to do with my weight! That freed me up to stop being so self-conscious in fitness classes, to stop thinking "the reason I can't do x, y, and z is because I'm too fat" and recognize "the reason she's farther into that pose than I am is because her shoulders are more open than mine." If a fat student who is just beginning yoga comes to class and sees everyone doing something that she can't do, it might really reassure her to know that the reason she can't do it is NOT her weight.

    Thank you again for writing about this. Love to you!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Good grief, I didn't realize I'd written so much. ;b

    ReplyDelete
  3. No judgment about a big body or a big comment. :) Thanks to both of you, Kimber and Satsumabug.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Lovely post! Fat people can certainly rock out yoga as well as anyone else. There are many great resources available; I have a list on the resources page of my website, Curvy Yoga (www.curvyyoga.com), including a list of size positive teachers from all over.

    Many thanks for sharing this message!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Stop calling them Fat Students/People...instead, call them overweight or something more appropriate. Sheesh, have some sensitivity!

    ReplyDelete
  6. I just made a complaint to CSWD about this website and its insensitivity toward full-figured people.. http://www.cswd.org/docs/legalaction.html

    ReplyDelete
  7. Dear Anonymous, I'm so sorry that you've taken offense at the use of the word "fat" in this blogpost. I certainly don't want to ever contribute to the negativity that overweight (the term you prefer) people encounter in the world. I'm using it in the way my fat-activist friend Marilyn Wann uses it in her book Fat!So? and the wonderful Ragen Chastain uses it in her blog, Dances With Fat. I definitely recommend that you check out these wonderful resources. Lots of weight-diversity activists dislike the use of euphemisms (like plumb, full-figured, etc.) and are currently working hard to reclaim the word "fat" from being equated with bad, lazy, unhealthy, and instead equate it to being simply a way of describing a normal body type. I don't equate fat with bad. Please substitute whatever word you prefer. Good luck on your journey!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Kimber, thank you SO MUCH for this blogpost and for your amazing response to "anonymous" above. YES. "OVERweight" is actually way more offensive to me than "fat" because it contains a value judgment WITHIN that actual word! I have been wanting to practice yoga for a while, but was living in Boulder, CO where yoga culture is like haute couture in the fashion world... in many different ways. Now I don't really have any yoga class options in my remote South Pacific island, but I would love any recommendations you might have for online videos! Thank you thank you again!

      Delete
  8. A lot of fat people have no problem with the word and use it freely. It's a descriptive word that has taken on a negative connotation and I for one am taking it back! I take my fat butt to yoga everyday and more often than not I am the biggest person in the room and rock out! I hope one day you can feel comfortable in your own skin and use whatever word described that best.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I love this post! Thank you so much for writing it and sharing the word that every boyd can be a yoga body. I also appreciate that you use the word fat! I don't mind most euphemisms (and love "curvy" actually for some reason... I think I just like the sound of the word, it's fun!), but I hate the word "overweight" as it implies that there is another weight I ought to be. Thanks again!

    ReplyDelete
  10. AnonymousApril 18, 2012 3:11 PM

    I just made a complaint to CSWD about this website and its insensitivity toward full-figured people..
    ************
    Chill out dude! Holy moly!
    Kimber thanks for this, I've been thin, and did yoga and I've been fat and did yoga and there IS a difference. Now I've just lost 20 lbs and find my belly doesn't get in the way like it used to(fatter) and doing locust pose isn't balancing on my belly.
    I agree, I wouldn't attend a class b/c of all the little "twigs" there. I have gotten upset with Yoga journal b/c they have very few article on
    Fat yogini!
    Here is a interesting blog post
    An Open Letter to the Fat Girl I Saw at Hot Yoga in New York City
    http://www.joshilynjackson.com/ftk/?p=1675
    I'm sure our anon in denial won't like it but too bad. :)
    I have lost 20 lbs and my body moves differently. I think yoga classes
    should be open to all body sizes, and to a extent they are, but there is a taboo, and invisible sign over the door "Fat people, do not enter". I love your Ganesha analogy!
    Until then I will keep doing my home practice! My dream would be to be a yoga teacher for Fat people,pain syndromes, Seniors or "Special needs yoga teacher" twigs need not apply!
    Namaste!

    ReplyDelete